Hiring.Camp

Café Supervisor

THE BARTOLOTTA RESTAURANTS

·

Aug 7, 2026

Location
MILWAUKEE, WI
Source
Paylocity

Description

Description

The Bartolotta Restaurants is a nationally recognized restaurant and catering organization co-founded by restaurateur Joe Bartolotta and his brother, two-time James Beard Award-winning Chef Paul Bartolotta. Since 1993, The Bartolotta Restaurants has grown to become the premier culinary brand in the Greater Milwaukee region, offering first-class service and cuisine across a portfolio of 17 one-of-a-kind restaurants and catering facilities. As a forward-thinking and respected company, we also give back to our community through Care-a-lotta, a charitable program that supports numerous nonprofit organizations throughout Milwaukee. 


At The Bartolotta Restaurants, we are committed to excellence in every aspect of our business, from the products we source to the food and service we deliver every day in our restaurants and catering venues. Our greatest asset in our company is our team members because, without them, we wouldn't be in business. 


We look for people who have what we call a "hospitality heart," characterized by a commitment to providing excellence, a passion for taking care of our guests, and a “can-do” attitude. We're a family-run business, and we consider our team members part of The Bartolotta Restaurants family. 


JOB PURPOSE:

The Café Supervisor is responsible for the day-to-day operation of the grab and go café area. The supervisor is ideally someone who is passionate about food quality, sanitation, and customer service. In addition, this individual is someone who is a problem solver with a strong work ethic and an ability to work with minimal supervision. The Café Supervisor is also responsible for sales, financial management, guest satisfaction and general café oversight. 


PRIMARY DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES:

  • Manage daily operation of the café.
  • Identify and communicate responsibilities with management ensuring objectives are met and guest service is achieved.
  • Manage and respond effectively and accurately to guest complaints.
  • Consistently review operations to identify any problems, concerns, and areas of improvement.
  • Manage the café to meet or exceed standards in food quality, safety, and cleanliness.
  • Manage food, beverage, and labor costs along with budgeting and P&L.
  • Manage weekly inventory and ordering of all products.
  • Create detailed reports on weekly, monthly, and annual sales revenues and expenses.

All Other Duties as Assigned 


 

Requirements

QUALIFICATION REQUIREMENTS:

  • Highly organized and self-directed.
  • Able to build relationships at all levels of the organization.
  • Exceptional interpersonal, oral, presentation and written communication skills.
  • Excellent project management skills.
  • Ability to work in fast-paced, changing environment.

EDUCATION and/or EXPERIENCE REQUIREMENTS:

  • Requires a minimum of one years’ experience in fast-casual dining concept.
  • Preferred experience with food and beverage knowledge.
  • Familiar with cashier software.

PHYSICAL REQUIREMENTS:

While performing the duties of this job, the employee is:  

  • Regularly required to talk, use repetitive motion, type, and hear.
  • Able to interact with staff and customers in an appropriate and professional manner.  
  • Frequently required to stand, walk, use hands and fingers to handle and feel, and reach with hands and arms.  
  • Able to read and write clearly.
  • Occasionally required to bend, kneel, crouch, climb stairs, and reach overhead.  
  • Able to lift up to 20 pounds at a time.
  • Able to work days, weekends, and holidays.



ADA Disclaimer: In developing this job description care was taken to include all competencies needed to successfully perform in this position. However, for Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) purposes, the essential functions of the job may or may not have been described for purposes of ADA reasonable accommodation. All reasonable accommodation requests will be reviewed and evaluated on a case-by-case basis.


Skills

Customer ServiceProject Management

Similar Jobs

30

Cafe Supervisor

Summerset·Prebbleton, Canterbury Region

Today

Cafe Supervisor

Skechers·USA: Distribution Center, US

5d ago

Cafe Supervisor

Elior UK·High St, Standish

1w ago

Cafe Supervisor

WSH Group·London, England·Remote

1w ago

Cafe Supervisor

Vivalon·San Rafael, CA

1w ago

Cafe Supervisor

Summerset·Hamilton, Waikato Region

1w ago

Cafe Supervisor

TOP POT DOUGHNUTS·Issaquah, WA

1w ago

Cafe Supervisor

TOP POT DOUGHNUTS·Seattle, WA

2w ago

Café Supervisor

Tfghospitality·Abu Dhabi, AE

2w ago

Café Supervisor

Outpost Natural Foods·Wauwatosa, WI

1mo ago

Café Supervisor

A24 Group·Horsham, West Sussex

3mo ago

Café Supervisor

Na Merlinentertainments·Kansas City, MO

1y+ ago

Cafe Supervisor

Au Bon Pain·Dartmouth MC, Lebanon

1y+ ago

Cafe Supervisor

Au Bon Pain·Brigham & Womens Hospital, Boston

1y+ ago

Cafe Supervisor

Au Bon Pain·22 S Greene St, Baltimore

1y+ ago

Cafe Supervisor

Au Bon Pain·300 Community Dr, Manhasset

1y+ ago

Cafe Supervisor

Au Bon Pain·Vanderbilt MC, Nashville

1y+ ago

Cafe Supervisor

MUNCH FIT LIMITED·London, England

1y+ ago

Cafe Supervisor - The British Museum

WSH Group·London, England

6d ago

Life Cafe Supervisor

Lifetime·Rancho San Clemente, US

6d ago

Assistant Cafe Supervisor

Primeinc·Pittston, PA

1w ago

Life Cafe Supervisor

Lifetime·Austin South Lamar, US

1w ago

Life Cafe Supervisor

Lifetime·Green Valley, US

1w ago

Guest Service Supervisor - Cafe Lead

Phipps Conservatory·Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

2w ago

Life Cafe Supervisor

Lifetime·Paradise Valley, US

2w ago

Life Cafe Supervisor

Lifetime·Woodstock, US

2w ago

The Café Supervisor

ACCOR·New Orleans, LA

2w ago

Cafe Supervisor (Coffee Shop / Food Service) – Full Time

Delavan Holdings·Delavan, WI

2w ago

Cafe Supervisor - Starting wage $21.25

East End Cooperative Inc·Pittsburgh, PA

3w ago

Life Cafe Supervisor

Lifetime·Bloomingdale, US

3w ago